Info Change India

Environment

Mon05292017

Last updateMon, 08 May 2017 3am

Font Size

Profile

Menu Style

Cpanel
You are here: Home | Environment | The paradox of environmentalism | The tribal's right

The tribal's right

By Michelle Chawla

Dahanu’s special environmental status has made little difference to the poverty-stricken Warli tribals, shunted out of the forests and lands they cultivated for generations. The 2006 Tribal Bill, on the other hand, goes a long way in granting them their rightful share of the forests

Read Part 1 of this series here
Read Part 2 of this series here
Read Part 3 of this series here

Read Part 4 of this series here

Shankar of Raytali village, Dahanu, retells the popular Warli folktale about the rat that takes away the grain from the fields. Called ‘The Rat's Right’, he explains that the rat was one of the earliest creatures to provide humans with the seeds to begin agriculture. Thus when they see the tops of their rice crop eaten up, the adivasis do not call the rat a thief, but say that it has taken its rightful share. The rat inevitably finds its role and space in the lives of the Warlis.  

Several other stories of wolves and ants, rabbits and tigers follow, revealing the rich cultural ecology and ethos of the community of Warlis, the tribal people of northwestern Maharashtra and south Gujarat.  

Numbering approximately half a million (Census of 1991), a majority of the Warlis live in Thane district of Maharashtra in tiny hamlets spread across the fringes of the picturesque Sahyadri mountain range. A deep environmental consciousness is reflected in their worldview, in which humans and nature are linked in a relationship that is celebrated in myth and reality. 

The folklore also records the history of oppression, brutality and resistance against the takeover of their forest homelands by the British and the loss of lands to Parsi and Marwari landlords and moneylenders. A tongue-in-cheek story tells how a Parsi landlord eventually usurped everything from the Warlis, even his wife!  

Of a total population of 3,31,829, in Maharashtra’s Dahanu taluka (Socio Economic Abstract, 2006-07, Thane district), 64.84% are tribal, belonging predominantly to the Warli tribe. Dispersed  across 174 villages in Dahanu, the Warlis are today a marginalised community.  

Brutally shunted out of the forests and their homelands during British rule, independence did not alter the harsh realities for these communities. With a majority of the forest lands taken over by the government, the adivasis lost their habitats and culture and took to settled and subsistence agriculture while still being dependent on the forests for food, fuel, medicine and in many cases cultivation.  

Some became daily wage labourers on farms, brick kilns and boats. The changes in the forest management system had a negative impact on their social and cultural lives. Low levels of literacy, malnourishment, poverty and deprivation are the realities of a once proud and brave Warli community.  

Moreover, the post-independence development agenda of modernising and integrating tribals into the mainstream, has been partial and fragmented, impacting the Warli identity and consciousness adversely. The struggle for access to forests, rights over land and minimum wages became the critical conflicts around which the Warlis have been struggling for the last several decades.  

In the current milieu with Dahanu being an environmentally protected region since 1991 and the passing of the Tribal Bill [Scheduled Tribes (Recognition of Forest Rights) Bill, 2006], it is critical to analyse whether these laws and notifications have played a role or contributed in changing the conditions of the tribal communities.  

Dahanu's environmental status and its forests  

At a brick kiln in the village of Ganjad in Dahanu, Jaanu Ravte bargains over the price of bricks to build a new home. “There are hardly any large-girthed trees left in the forest for me to build with,” he states when asked why he is not constructing a traditional adivasi home. While this may seem ironic given that the village is in the declared ecologically fragile zone of Dahanu taluka, it is the reality in most parts of the region.  

Envisaging the potential damage to the tribal area due to industrialisation, the ministry of environment and forests declared Dahanu an ecologically fragile region in 1991, specifically stating that the tribal culture needed to be protected. With this, Dahanu's forests -- approximately 45.91% (46,706 hectares) of the total lands -- became protected, with no polluting industries, quarrying or commercial felling permitted in the region. Dahanu has 34,720 hectares declared reserved forests and 11,986 hectares as protected forests.   

However, according to Deputy Conservator of Forests, Dahanu division, Mishra, “Despite these restrictions, there has been illegal commercial logging, forest fires, felling for energy use and shifting cultivation that has caused degradation of the forests.”  While the forest department claims a lack of support from the community, tribal activists state that the forest department has no genuine commitment in protecting the forests.  

“The reality is that the pressures on the Warli community to eke out a livelihood from their eroding forestlands has increased tremendously, with the growing urbanisation and industrialisation all around – Mumbai to the south and the Vapi-Valsad industrial corridor to the north. Meanwhile, systematic and large-scale efforts to save and rejuvenate the forests in partnership with the community have not taken place simultaneously,” states Lahani Tandel, tribal leader and sarpanch of Sogve panchayat.  

While the community has restricted access to the forests for fuel, other minor forest produce, and cultivation, the sense of ownership and thereby participation in conservation is absent in most areas.  

For its part, the Dahanu Taluka Environment Protection Authority (DTEPA) appointed by the Supreme Court to oversee Dahanu's development, has played an important role in ensuring that afforestation projects are undertaken and maintained for the benefit of the community. The DTEPA has sanctioned   nine projects where more than 70 hectares of land have been brought under afforestation. Moreover, acting like a watchdog, it has ensured that any illegal stone quarrying activity in the forests is immediately stopped and no new quarries are permitted.  

Nevertheless, these legal mechanisms have had a limited role to play in a reality that is far more complex.  

Tribal bill and justice 

For the communities in Dahanu, the passing of the recent Tribal Bill that recognised their rights was a step at reversing the historical injustice they had faced at the hands of the colonial and modern State.  

Brian Lobo, of the Kashtkari Sanghatana, a grassroots movement that actively campaigned for the Tribal Bill and is involved in its implementation in Dahanu, believes that  “the Bill is a culmination of a struggle that has gone on for 200 years”. “For us,” he continues, “it is one step closer to the democratisation of forests and towards the dismantling of the forest bureaucracy that controlled the jungle and abused the adivasis. We definitely believe that the Bill can change the reality of forest-dwelling communities given that it provides power to the people to control the forest.” 

According to estimates provided by the forest department in Dahanu, there are currently approximately 5,500 individual claims for regularisation of forest plots. Dighe, Deputy Conservator of Forests, Dahanu, who has mixed reactions to the bill and seems reluctant to see its implementation, admits that most claims are for fairly small sizes of land, granted to the communities several decades ago and not regularised till now. More importantly most claims do not exceed a few gunthas of land, contrary to propaganda stating that the bill would amount to a land grab by brokers and the land mafia.  

The regularisation and eventual handing over of these plots to the tribals will indeed be a huge victory for the community and enhance the livelihood of the families.  

However, the most powerful sections of the Act concern community rights to manage, protect and conserve its forests. While the state government and forest bureaucracy continue to ignore these aspects of the bill, the community’s preparedness to take control of this resource also seems lacking. 

For the Tribal Bill to significantly alter the power equations and grant control of the forests to the adivasis, communities must be united and work towards conserving and protecting a resource that is collectively owned.  

Conclusion 

While the environmental legislations in Dahanu, may have played some role in allowing the Warlis to retain a measure of their tribal ethos and identity, the Tribal Bill goes a longer way in granting them their rightful share of the forests. However, much more would need to be done to grant the Warlis their rightful place in society. In the meanwhile, the struggle for the Warlis continues.  

(This is the concluding part of Michelle Chawla’s  series on the conflict between environment-protection, development and livelihoods in the protected area of Dahanu. Michelle has a Master’s degree in social work and is founder and trustee of the Tamarind Tree Trust, which is located on a chickoo farm in Dahanu, Maharashtra, and works on developmental and environmental issues in Dahanu. This series was researched as part of the Infochange Media Fellowships 2008.) 

Infochange News & Features, July 2009 

Backgrounders

Agriculture And Food Security : Background & Perspective

Agriculture And Food Security : Background & Perspective

By Devinder Sharma

Pre-Independence India suffered repeated famines, drought and food shortages. But following the Green Revolution in the '60s, yields and foodstocks rose manifold. Now, 30 years later, Indian farmers have realised the follies of their tryst with intensive agriculture. Despite 70 per ...

READ MORE

Loading...

Analysis

The organic foods divide in India

The organic foods divide in India

By Rahul Goswami

The divide between farmers growing and selling organic produce in India and the major organic foods and beverages retailers is widening, to the detriment of organic farmers. This was evident at Biofach India 2013 held in Bengaluru

READ MORE

Loading...

Features

Ragi over rice

Ragi over rice

By Ananda Siddhartha

As in the rest of India, in Pavagada taluka of Karnataka, ragi is losing out to rice, groundnut and other cash crops. Until 15 years ago, it was the reverse. What are the market and policy pressures that have caused this reversal, and what are its consequences on health and nutri...

READ MORE

Loading...

Books & Reports

Vertical farms

Vertical farms

By Sudhirendar Sharma

A new book by Dickson Despommier posits the farm of the future as a vertical farm over 30 floors in any city centre. Powered by renewable energies a vertical farm could meet the food needs of 50,000 people, consume 70-95% less water, restrict the use of harmful agro-chemicals and...

READ MORE

Loading...

Punjab Series

Nation's food bowl in crisis

By Anosh Malekar

When the state that was the country's biggest agricultural success story in the 1970s tops the list of indebted farmers, it is obvious that there is something very rotten in the state of agriculture in the country. A three-part series that looks at the agriculture crisis in India's fo...

READ MORE

Loading...

News

Stories of change

Nalbari farmers resume cultivation after 25 years

By Ratna Bharali Taukdar

Thousands of farmers in Borigog-Barbhag block, in lower Assam’s Nalbari district, joined hands to dredge a 15-km stretch of a water channel that had blocked and flooded farmlands across 50 villages. For 25 years, farmers had abandoned work on their waterlogged lands. No...

READ MORE

Loading...

Changemakers

Urban poverty and the food crisis

A grain in an empty bowl: Government services in the urban context

By Maheen Mirza

Anganwadis, ICDS and PDS are huge government programmes meant to cater to the health and nutritional requirements of the poor. Yet 72.4% of urban poor children in Madhya Pradesh are underweight, 60.4% are undernourished and almost nine out of 10 are anaemic. The fifth and final part o...

READ MORE

Loading...

Backgrounders

IT And Development : Background & Perspective

IT And Development : Background & Perspective

By Aditya Dev Sood

What use can a computer be to someone earning less than a dollar a day? What use is information technology in a country that has a low penetration of telephony and computers, where even electricity is not assured, and where millions are still illiterate? These are standard questions...

READ MORE

Loading...

Analysis

Free culture for a free society

By V Sasi Kumar

What is it that prompts a group of people in Calicut to start the Chamba Swatantra Cinema Project? How did the world move from copyrights over knowledge, introduced in the 16th-18th centuries and codified as the Statute of Anne, to free software, free knowledge and free culture? And w...

READ MORE

Loading...

Features

Do you want to be watched?

The new rules for surveillance under the IT Act are an assault on our freedom. They also seem misguided, says Sunil Abraham . How many terrorists or criminals will be arrested in India thanks to the new ID requirements at cybercafés or a ban on public wi-fi? Intelligence work cannot be replaced...

READ MORE

Loading...

Changemakers

Stories of change

The people's voice

By Sherna Gandhy

Every citizen in this country has a right to be heard. But what happens when you live in an area where no mainstream media organisation bothers to penetrate, and when you speak a language no media organisation knows or understands? CGNet Swara uses mobile telephony to break through th...

READ MORE

Loading...

News

India turns to ICT for better delivery of welfare schemes

Bihar will become the first state in the country to videograph the distribution of PDS coupons to weed out ineligible recipients. And the Union human resources ministry proposes to use a cheap, indigenously made tablet PC to record BPL and caste data

READ MORE

Loading...

Digital Divides

OPENSPACE

 OpenSpace Talk Think Act for change
Our youth forum

KIDSFORCHANGE

Food diaries of poor children
Stories for children

VIDEOS

In Search of My Home
Infochange documentaries

AUDIO FILES

The visible scares of Kashmir
Infochange audio stories

FILM FORUM

REVIEWS OF FILMS
Reviews of documentary films