Info Change India

Disabilities

Mon05292017

Last updateMon, 08 May 2017 3am

Font Size

Profile

Menu Style

Cpanel
You are here: Home | Disabilities | Disabled sexualities | Violence and disabled women

Violence and disabled women

By Richa Kaul Padte

A more inclusive and diverse understanding of sex is bringing queer theory together with a disability-rights discourse to legitimise what was previously considered ‘deviant’ or ‘incorrect’

violence, disabled women

On August 3, 2012, a Special Rapporteur’s ‘Report on Violence Against Women with Disabilities’ was released for presentation to the United Nations General Assembly. Spanning research from countries across the world, the report states, ‘Although women with disabilities experience many of the same forms of violence that all women experience, when gender, disability and other factors intersect the violence against them takes on unique forms, has unique causes and results in unique consequences’ (p 4). Facing a double discrimination because of their dually gendered and impaired bodies (or minds), women with disabilities experience stereotypes and prejudices that ‘cultivate a psychological sense of invisibility, self-estrangement, and/or powerlessness’. The internalisation of these prejudices often leads women with disabilities who face violence – and in particular, sexual violence – to feel a sense of shame or guilt at having brought it upon themselves. Compounded with the assumed asexuality of disabled women, this multi-layered manifestation of discrimination leads to a global situation where women with disabilities often face higher levels of violence as compared to their nondisabled counterparts.

A blogger on the website Stop Street Sexual Harassment writes, ‘The first time I went out in my wheelchair my mum and I were so shocked when an aggressive man leaned over me, shook my wheelchair and quickly thrust his groin in my face as he squeezed past. There was about three feet of space in front of us he could have easily used without pressing up against me or moving my chair at all. I was 16. The second and third time a man did "the groin thing" it still bothered me…I felt dirty. I felt ashamed. I even blamed myself.’

Women walking, travelling or standing on the streets of India’s busy cities, towns and even rural villages are consistently subjected to the message that public space is not theirs. The entrance and presentation of their bodies in the public realm – very simply, by being there – is a transgression of sorts; a transgression that deserves whatever punishment is to follow. If the sexual harassment of women is somehow seen as ‘deserved’ because of the gendering of public spaces, there is a double transgression at play in the case of women with disabilities. The intersection of their impairments with their gender means that while all women face sexual harassment, disabled women face forms of harassment that either take advantage of or explicitly refer to their impairments. Visually impaired women speak of their experiences navigating city spaces, where the ‘help’ offered while crossing a road or boarding a train can – and often does – quickly transform into a sexualised grope or hold upon their bodies. Hearing-impaired working women sometimes feel their male colleagues looking at them in a sexualised way, though their exact words are always unheard.

Due to limited interactions with nondisabled women – a consequence of ‘special’ education, a dearth of accessibility-related infrastructure, the protectiveness of parents, or isolation from others due to family shame – disabled women often feel alone in their experiences of sexual harassment, or worse, believe they deserve it. Vanita, a young Mumbai-based visually impaired woman says, “I would earlier think that men harass me because I can't see. But when I spoke to other blind and sighted friends I came to know that all women face this. Only that we blind are more prone. Then I understood that I should be confident, strong, and use my wits in such a situation. That is the way to handle and react.”

As sexual violence progresses from verbal harassment to physical violence (most often assault or rape) news reports from across the country indicate the high levels of sexual assault frequently faced by women with disabilities. The shame that survivors of rape often feel after the attack may be intensified for women with disabilities, who are made to believe by their rapists that they should be ‘grateful’ for any sexual attention they receive. This leads back to the harmful myth that presumes women with disabilities are asexual and unattractive, and contributes to a sense of guilt that they have brought the attack upon themselves simply by virtue of being disabled. Furthermore, this presumption of asexuality means that women with disabilities are frequently disbelieved by those around them if they come forward about sexual abuse, because many assume that they do not qualify as sexually desirable. The well-established fact that rape is not about desire or sex, but about power, eludes even the legal system. As Saptarshi Mandal writes, ‘Court judgments show that the main reason why cases of sexual assault against disabled women fail to get the accused convicted is that the evidentiary value of their testimony is not taken seriously during the trial in the lower courts.’ Asexualised, dehumanised, and rendered voiceless by the very systems designed to protect them, women with disabilities most often suffer their experiences of sexual assault in silence – a phenomenon that the UN Special Rapporteur’s findings suggest is of global concern.

And violence, like many other things, often begins at home. A research study conducted by Mumbai-based NGO SNEHA found that of the 400 women with disabilities surveyed, 21% had experienced some form of domestic violence, but only half that number had told anyone about it. Furthermore, 43% of the women interviewed believed that some form of violence against them was justified due to their impairments. Taking place within the context of a family home where women with disabilities are considered a burden on the family or a source of shame, the violence faced by disabled women is often very much a result of their impairments. Withholding support including canes, wheelchairs, medicines and other forms of assistance are common manifestations of family-based violence that women with disabilities experience. Many families are ashamed by their disabled children (since disability is often considered to be a marker of retribution for past-life sins), and seek to isolate or hide them away from outsiders, or even from other family members. Instances of isolation are extremely high amongst disabled girls in particular, who have their movements restricted by those claiming to ‘protect’ them. It is within these tightly controlled environments that experiences of sexual abuse take place, and without the knowledge, experience or permission to approach the outside world, the majority of this abuse goes unreported. Also, women with disabilities are told that they must be grateful for the responsibility their families or husbands bear in ‘tolerating’ and ‘accommodating’ them, which leads to a further unwillingness to speak out about violence – often seen as part and parcel of living with a disability.

The Special Rapporteur’s report highlights a worldwide issue of abuse that has recently found its way into Indian national news: the forced sterilisation of women with disabilities. Fuelled by the misconception that disabled women are more likely to give birth to disabled children (despite the fact that a disabled and nondisabled woman have an equal chance of producing a disabled child) or that women with disabilities will be unable to raise children, the forced sterilisation of women with disabilities is a global phenomenon. In addition to this, the alarming rates of rape and sexual assault against women with disabilities means that the ‘protective’ measure of sterilisation is often used to prevent unwanted pregnancies arising from unwanted sex. The use of sterilisation as a means to address sexual assault is yet another terrifying comment on the ways in which the rape of all women is consistently trivialised into a ‘causes or consequences’ mentality, with little emphasis placed on the violence of the assault itself. Forced sterilisation is also often performed as a hysterectomy to serve as a solution to ‘menstrual management’, particularly in the case of girls with mental disabilities (1): another indicator of the ways in which societal constructions of the female reproductive system position women’s bodies as something to be controlled.

As disability rights groups and women’s organisations begin a stronger dialogue with one another – evidenced through initiatives such as CREA’s 2011 Count Me In! Conference (bringing together women with disabilities, lesbian women, trans women, sex workers and activists from across South Asia), more concerted and far-reaching efforts can be made to end all forms of gender-based violence. The Special Rapporteur states: ‘Women with disabilities should be allowed the opportunity and provided with the necessary accommodations to enable them to participate fully in forums discussing the empowerment of women and gender equality. Collaboration within women’s rights groups and disabled peoples organisations and with other stakeholders involved in  activities to combat violence against women should be enhanced with a  view towards including women with disabilities in related dialogue, strategy and institution-building processes’ (p 23).  Through an understanding that violence against ­all women – irrespective of disability – is perpetuated through the pervasive structures of patriarchy and capitalism, disabled and nondisabled women can fight against violence together with greater strength, on common grounds, and in larger numbers.

Endnotes

1.This series has so far looked only at women with physical impairments, and will devote a separate article to the broad spectrum of mental disabilities, which will aim to highlight the separate laws and nuances that come into play.

(Richa Kaul Padte is a freelance writer and feminist activist living between Bombay and Goa. She was the co-author and project coordinator of www.sexualityanddisability.org, an online initiative by Point of View and CREA)

Infochange News & Features, January 2013

Backgrounders

Agriculture And Food Security : Background & Perspective

Agriculture And Food Security : Background & Perspective

By Devinder Sharma

Pre-Independence India suffered repeated famines, drought and food shortages. But following the Green Revolution in the '60s, yields and foodstocks rose manifold. Now, 30 years later, Indian farmers have realised the follies of their tryst with intensive agriculture. Despite 70 per ...

READ MORE

Loading...

Analysis

The organic foods divide in India

The organic foods divide in India

By Rahul Goswami

The divide between farmers growing and selling organic produce in India and the major organic foods and beverages retailers is widening, to the detriment of organic farmers. This was evident at Biofach India 2013 held in Bengaluru

READ MORE

Loading...

Features

Ragi over rice

Ragi over rice

By Ananda Siddhartha

As in the rest of India, in Pavagada taluka of Karnataka, ragi is losing out to rice, groundnut and other cash crops. Until 15 years ago, it was the reverse. What are the market and policy pressures that have caused this reversal, and what are its consequences on health and nutri...

READ MORE

Loading...

Books & Reports

Vertical farms

Vertical farms

By Sudhirendar Sharma

A new book by Dickson Despommier posits the farm of the future as a vertical farm over 30 floors in any city centre. Powered by renewable energies a vertical farm could meet the food needs of 50,000 people, consume 70-95% less water, restrict the use of harmful agro-chemicals and...

READ MORE

Loading...

Punjab Series

Nation's food bowl in crisis

By Anosh Malekar

When the state that was the country's biggest agricultural success story in the 1970s tops the list of indebted farmers, it is obvious that there is something very rotten in the state of agriculture in the country. A three-part series that looks at the agriculture crisis in India's fo...

READ MORE

Loading...

News

Stories of change

Nalbari farmers resume cultivation after 25 years

By Ratna Bharali Taukdar

Thousands of farmers in Borigog-Barbhag block, in lower Assam’s Nalbari district, joined hands to dredge a 15-km stretch of a water channel that had blocked and flooded farmlands across 50 villages. For 25 years, farmers had abandoned work on their waterlogged lands. No...

READ MORE

Loading...

Changemakers

Urban poverty and the food crisis

A grain in an empty bowl: Government services in the urban context

By Maheen Mirza

Anganwadis, ICDS and PDS are huge government programmes meant to cater to the health and nutritional requirements of the poor. Yet 72.4% of urban poor children in Madhya Pradesh are underweight, 60.4% are undernourished and almost nine out of 10 are anaemic. The fifth and final part o...

READ MORE

Loading...

Backgrounders

IT And Development : Background & Perspective

IT And Development : Background & Perspective

By Aditya Dev Sood

What use can a computer be to someone earning less than a dollar a day? What use is information technology in a country that has a low penetration of telephony and computers, where even electricity is not assured, and where millions are still illiterate? These are standard questions...

READ MORE

Loading...

Analysis

Free culture for a free society

By V Sasi Kumar

What is it that prompts a group of people in Calicut to start the Chamba Swatantra Cinema Project? How did the world move from copyrights over knowledge, introduced in the 16th-18th centuries and codified as the Statute of Anne, to free software, free knowledge and free culture? And w...

READ MORE

Loading...

Features

Do you want to be watched?

The new rules for surveillance under the IT Act are an assault on our freedom. They also seem misguided, says Sunil Abraham . How many terrorists or criminals will be arrested in India thanks to the new ID requirements at cybercafés or a ban on public wi-fi? Intelligence work cannot be replaced...

READ MORE

Loading...

Changemakers

Stories of change

The people's voice

By Sherna Gandhy

Every citizen in this country has a right to be heard. But what happens when you live in an area where no mainstream media organisation bothers to penetrate, and when you speak a language no media organisation knows or understands? CGNet Swara uses mobile telephony to break through th...

READ MORE

Loading...

News

India turns to ICT for better delivery of welfare schemes

Bihar will become the first state in the country to videograph the distribution of PDS coupons to weed out ineligible recipients. And the Union human resources ministry proposes to use a cheap, indigenously made tablet PC to record BPL and caste data

READ MORE

Loading...

Digital Divides

OPENSPACE

 OpenSpace Talk Think Act for change
Our youth forum

KIDSFORCHANGE

Food diaries of poor children
Stories for children

VIDEOS

In Search of My Home
Infochange documentaries

AUDIO FILES

The visible scares of Kashmir
Infochange audio stories

FILM FORUM

REVIEWS OF FILMS
Reviews of documentary films